AFTER: Removing the wall opened up the space, while Carrara marble tile on the walls and floor brought the room into the current decade.

Forteza replaced the plumbing, electrical and insulation, things he always recommends for homes built in the 1940s and ’50s. “These homes have seen their time,” he says. “Ninety-five percent of the time when you gut out, you will see dry rot, termite-infested wood — you want to fix that. Putting new tile down won’t fix what’s wrong inside the walls.”

But while newer homes won’t have these kinds of problems, Forteza says you should be wary of past remodel projects too. “You never know what quality a previous homeowner instituted,” he says. In other words, always build a 10 to 20 percent contingency into your budget, no matter what the size of your bathroom.

Wall tile: Carrara marble, 4 by 12 inches, Home Depot; floor tile: Carrara marble, 12 by 12 inches, Home Depot; sink: Stinson undermount in white (442007-U-0), Sterling by Kohler; faucet: Grandera widespread low spout lavatory (20418000), Grohe; bathtub: Villager in white, 32 by 60 inches, Kohler; tub spout: Grandera, 9¼ inches, Grohe; thermostat trim with diverter: Metris C in chrome (15753001), Hansgrohe; hand shower: Movario 5 (28444000), Grohe

Forteza extended the Caesarstone countertop above the toilet, a move he likes to do in compact bathrooms whenever he can. “That 6 or 7 inches of depth gives a lot of counter space,” he says.

Toilet: Dual Force in white (402086-0), Sterling by Kohler; wall color: Cold Wind (DE6351), flat, Dunn-Edwards; vanity: maple, custom; vanity color: Gray (2121-10), Benjamin Moore; countertop: Frost White, Caesarstone

These drawings show the tile layout.

Walls moved: No, but one nonstructural half-wall was removed.
Plumbing moved: Yes. Everything was reconfigured. The shower head switched walls, and the sink plumbing was rerouted from the wall up through the floor.
Plumbing replaced: Yes, and electrical
Professionals hired: Forteza acted as designer and builder.
Special features: Frameless glass without door. “It makes it look nice and clean,” Forteza says.
Splurges: Plumbing fixtures and custom cabinets. “Try to splurge and be happy,” Forteza says. “The difference between a Home Depot cabinet and a custom cabinet is not going to cost your mortgage. You’re going to be looking at it every single day. You might as well save up more and be happy with it.”
Savings: Off-the-shelf tile from a big-box store. “I usually buy tiles from a special tile supplier, but I saw this for a bargain price and bought a bunch,” he says. He also saved on design and building fees by doing the work himself. ♦︎

AFTER: Designer Julia Mack began with a mostly white tile palette, which, like the frameless glass shower enclosure, gives the illusion of more space. The simple color scheme, unlike the dicey yellow from before, has built-in staying power. “I prefer to keep tile neutral because it will be there for a long time and you don’t want to get tired of colors,” Mack says. “If you really want color, add it through wall paint that can be easily changed, or towels and accessories.”

The glossy white tile features a subtle horizontal stripe, and Mack thought this would look good paired with small matte black tile installed in a herringbone pattern on the floor. “Once these two items were finalized, I knew that the large pearl inlaid mirror was imperative,” Mack says. “It adds a modern quality plus some needed pattern and interest to the white space.”

Walls moved: No
Plumbing moved: No
Plumbing replaced: Yes
Professionals hired: Donald Meta (contractor), Julia Mack of Julia Mack Design (interior design)
Special features: A new glass shower enclosure that visually expands the space
Splurges: Tiled shower niche with two tiled shelves
Savings: Mack kept the existing lighting and bought an inexpensive sink cabinet from Ikea.

Sink cabinet: Godmorgon/Odensvik, Ikea; wall and floor tile: Porcelanosa; faucet and glass shower enclosure: Porcelanosa; toilet and bathtub: Duravit; mirror: charcoal mother of pearl, ABC Carpet and Home ♦︎

BEFORE: Built in 1959, the bathroom still featured the same ceramic tile with stuck-on soap dishes and an ineffective shower door. A pedestal sink lacked storage, and there were no niches to make up for it.

The owners had been living in this Central Park West condo for 25 years and were tired of the way the bathroom looked.

AFTER: The homeowners wanted something “classic yet elegant and somewhat feminine,” Pett says. She gutted the space down to the studs and started fresh. She covered the floor and walls in Thassos marble tile, with hints of blue on the floor and in the grout, a nod to one of the homeowner’s Greek heritage.

Sink: undermount, Kohler; countertop: Caesarstone; faucet, toilet and towel bar: Toto; shower head, arm and body spray: Kohler; vanity: Furniture Guild; medicine cabinet and shower door enclosure: Lexington, GlassCrafters; wall tile: white Thassos marble subway tile; floor tile: Blue Celeste and Thassos marble mosaic; shower base tile: Blue Celeste slabs; niche tile: Blue Celeste and white Thassos marble slabs

BEFORE: The couple turned their attention to what previous owners had described as a dressing room (shown here) right off the master bedroom. While the previous owners had been using the space for storage, Press saw it as a perfect opportunity to create an en suitebathroom. (To make up for what would’ve been lost closet space, they converted three bedrooms into two and used the remaining space to create a walk-in closet.)

The ladder seen here leads to a green wheel that firefighters can use to turn off the sprinkler system once a fire is under control. Press and Potter’s architect, George Ranalli, originally said that regulations prevented him from touching the mechanism and that the couple would have to shower next to the ladder. After some research, however, Ranalli discovered a regulation chain system that fits over the wheel.

AFTER: Press and Potter spared no expense in the new bathroom. Being in Tribeca, they knew that if they were to sell the loft in the future, the bathroom would have to appeal to high-end clients. “I wanted it to be beautiful,” Press says.

Mosaic Carrara marble tile covers the walls up to 8 feet and is capped with a black marble border tile. Carrara marble in a basket-weave pattern adorns the floor. Press estimates she spent $7,300 on tile and $7,800 on installation.

Here you can see the required sprinkler wheel with the chain system.

Floor tile: Bianco Carrara marble with Nero Marquina dots in basket-weave mosaic; wall tile: Carrara marble, polished white, mosaic offset brick pattern; border tile: polished black velvet marble, square mosaic, ⅝ inch

A wall-mounted toilet and recessed medicine cabinet make the most of the tight quarters, while mirrors help create more visual space.

Toilet: Aquia wall-hung with in-wall tank in Cotton, Toto; faucet, toilet paper holder and towel ring: Le Verre and La Crosse, Phylrich; vanity: Ronbow Venice, 30 and 9/16 inches; countertop: Carrara marble; sconces: Sophie 1 in polished nickel (WB1724PN), Murray Feiss; medicine cabinet:framed lit right-opening inset, large, Restoration Hardware

Polished nickel wall hooks, towel bar and towel rack provide storage options.

Double towel bar: Nicole, 24 inches, Alno; towel rack: Nicole, 24 inches, Alno; robe hook: Nicole, Alno

Carrara marble tile in a basket-weave pattern lines two shower niches, connecting the shower to the floor tile.

Shower head: Highgate exposed thermostatic system with 6-inch shower rose and white porcelain lever handles, Waterworks

AFTER: Payling and her husband, Larry Stanker, hired a contractor, Gene George, to gut the space down to the studs. Payling then set out choosing materials and fixtures for George to install.

Payling looked for a vanity with an undermount sink and lots of storage, but she couldn’t find one she liked in her price range. She saw a pedestal sink she really liked, but it didn’t offer any storage. Then she came across a photo on Houzz of recessed storage set between wall studs. She had her contractor build a cabinet into the wall studs behind the door, and that solved her storage dilemma.

Payling says that not having a designer helped her cut down on cost, but it also opened the door for a few mistakes to slip through. For example, she wished she had been present when the wall tile went up. She would’ve had the light switches installed higher so the tile wouldn’t have to be cut and worked around them. “But this was a DIY project, and I’m not a designer, so I don’t freak out about that stuff too much,” she says.

Mirror: Messina, Howard Elliott; sink: English turn pedestal, Home Depot; sconces:Eurofase Fountaine Collection, Home Depot; faucet: Santiago, Pfister

BEFORE: The original vanity and recessed medicine cabinet didn’t offer much storage, and when the couple’s college-age daughter was in town, everything ended up on the counter.

The couple also wanted to do away with the plastic shower-tub insert and the gold-colored accents.

AFTER: Payling splurged on the white Thassos marble tile with Blue Celeste dots for the floor; she saved by going with inexpensive ceramic tile for the shower and walls, both of which she spiffed up with glass and marble tile accents.

Payling also would’ve liked the toilet tank to touch the wall behind it rather than have a gap of a couple of inches — another design detail she feels could have been prevented if she had hired a designer or been present at installation.

Floor tile: Octave white Thassos with Blue Celeste dots; bathtub accent: Waterscape glass and marble, Allure; wainscot glass tile: Loft Crescent Cool Springs; wall and shower tile: ceramic, Lowe’s; bathtub: Devonshire jetted, Kohler; toilet: Devonshire comfort height two-piece elongated, Kohler

Here you can see the recessed cabinet storage behind the bathroom door. The cabinets hold cleaning supplies, extra toothpaste and soap, and can even hold toilet paper rolls, as long as they’re not the big fluffy kind. A linen closet across the hall also adds storage.

“I’m thrilled with how it turned out,” Payling says. “It went from dark and dingy to light and bright.”

Walls moved: No
Plumbing moved: No
Plumbing replaced: No
Professionals hired: Gene George (contractor)
Special features: Recessed wall cabinets; marble floor tile, glass and marble accent tile
Splurges: Marble floor tile
Savings: Basic off-the-shelf wall and shower tile. Payling also saved by acting as her own designer. ♦︎

More: How Much Does a Bathroom Remodel Cost?
See more bathroom makeovers